Black bear in a tree

Top 5 Restaurants at The Island in Pigeon Forge You Should Try

Timberwood Grill
March 2, 2024

You know there are a ton of fun things to do at The Island in Pigeon Forge. Did you know there are a ton of restaurant options there too? You’ll find a variety of restaurants at The Island in Pigeon Forge, from pizza to Southern cuisine. Check out these top 5 restaurants at The Island in Pigeon Forge you should try:

1. Paula Deen’s Family Kitchen

paula deen's family kitchen

Out of all of The Island in Pigeon Forge restaurants, one of the most popular is Paula Deen’s Family Kitchen. When you want a great meal with a ton of Southern foods, Paula Deen’s Family Kitchen is the place to eat for any food you want to try. This restaurant serves food family style, which means you choose a few entrees and sides for the whole table to share. If you visit for breakfast, be sure to try the chicken and biscuits, apple cinnamon French toast, and breakfast casserole. Some of the foods you can get for lunch or include meatloaf, fried chicken, chicken and dumplings, collard greens, and broccoli casserole. For lunch and dinner, you also get to choose a dessert. They have butter cake, seasonal fruit cobbler, or banana pudding. Paula Deen’s serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

2. Timberwood Grill

For classic American food, try Timberwood Grill, one of the locally owned restaurants at The Island in Pigeon Forge. Start out with fried mac and cheese bites, pork nachos, or a sampler for a little bit of everything. You can get strawberry chicken salad or salmon and avocado salad for your meal. There’s also a barbecue chicken sandwich and a few different burgers. Get the baby back ribs, fish and chips, fried shrimp, or one of the other entrees. Timberwood Grill has a few signature cocktails, such as the Jack Daniels Slushie, you won’t want to miss out on.

3. Mellow Mushroom

mellow mushroom

If you’re in the mood for pizza or Italian, head over to Mellow Mushroom. You can create your own pizza from a huge variety of toppings or try one of their signature pies. The Kosmic Karma has feta cheese, mozzarella, spinach, sun dried roasted tomatoes, roma tomatoes, and then is topped with pesto. The Funky Q. Chicken has barbecue chicken with cheddar and mozzarella cheese, caramelized onions, bacon, and topped with barbecue sauce. Mellow Mushroom also has salads, calzones, and hoagies. Don’t miss out on these other pizza places in Pigeon Forge!

4. Dick’s Last Resort

For a unique experience, you should eat at Dick’s Last Resort. You won’t find traditional customer service. At this restaurant at The Island in Pigeon Forge, it’s their job to insult you as much as possible. Start out with spinach and artichoke dip, fried alligator bites, or onion rings. For the entree, you can get Nashville hot chicken, low country boil, tacos, mac and cheese, and much more. Dick’s Last Resort is one of the best Island in Pigeon Forge restaurants to go to for good food, good drinks, and a good time.

5. Margaritaville

margaritaville pigeon forge

If you want to feel like you’ve stepped out of the mountains onto an island, you should eat at Margaritaville. They have a ton of seafood options, from seafood mac and cheese to cajun shrimp and grits. You can also get salad, burgers, or sandwiches. You can’t visit Margaritaville without trying one of their drinks! You’ll find every single flavor of margarita you can think of. If you want a different cocktail, try the Tsunami or Landshark Mule. Don’t miss these other seafood restaurants in Gatlinburg too!

These restaurants at The Island in Pigeon Forge are great options for your meal while you’re having fun. Want to know what else you should do after visiting these Island in Pigeon Forge restaurants? Find out everything there is to do at The Island in Pigeon Forge.