Gift Certificates are Great for Any Occasion! Click here for details!
old mill creamery best ice cream in Pigeon forge tn

Where to Get the Best Ice Cream in Pigeon Forge TN


If you have a sweet tooth and love ice cream, then you’re in luck! You’ll find amazing ice cream shops up and down the Pigeon Forge Parkway, so whether you’re shopping, exploring museums, or visiting the top attractions, you can enjoy a cold cone, shake, sundae, or another yummy scoop of your favorite flavor. Keep reading to find out where to get the best ice cream in Pigeon Forge TN!

Buzzed Bull Creamery

buzzed bull creamery At Buzzed Bull Creamery, the delicious ice cream combinations are truly endless! You can make the ice cream sundae or shake of your dreams, and those over the age of 21 can choose to make theirs “buzzed” (alcohol-infused) with your liquor of choice! Two of the fan-favorite specialties are Tiger Stripes – chocolate peanut butter ice cream, peanut butter cups, peanut butter sauce, and spiced rum – and Dreamsicle – orange cake batter ice cream, waffle cone pieces, whipped cream, and orange vodka.

Old Mill Creamery

The Old Mill in Pigeon Forge is one of the most iconic areas to explore, with a large general store, several specialty shops, a distillery, and most importantly, an old-fashioned ice cream shop! The Old Mill Creamery uses simple ingredients to make delicious flavors of ice cream; some of their specialties include Oatmeal Cream Pie, Banana Pudding, Salted Caramel, and Whiskey Ribbon.  

Island Creamery

the Island creamery in Pigeon forgeAfter enjoying a meal at one of the restaurants at The Island in Pigeon Forge, finish with a little something sweet from Island Creamery! Another place to get the best ice cream in Pigeon Forge TN, this shop is your one-stop shop, from chocolate-dipped waffle cones to smoothies, cookies, and more. You’ll be amazed at how many ice cream flavors there are to choose from!

The Yard Milkshake Bar

Be prepared for a sugar rush when you visit The Yard in Lumberjack Square! This milkshake bar serves the most elaborate milkshakes, with whole slices of cheesecakes, cookies, brownies, and frosting-covered rims on top! They even have an exclusive Dolly Parton-inspired creation made with strawberry cheesecake ice cream, rainbow marshmallow drizzle, a vanilla icing rim, plus a white chocolate strawberry cookie dough pop and rainbow whipped cream and sprinkles on top!

Cruze Farm

Cruze farm seviervilleTechnically, Cruze Farm is located just over the boundary in Sevierville, but it’s too good not to mention! Also located on the Parkway, it’s right next to SkyLand Ranch and across the road from the Tanger Outlet Mall, perfect for grabbing a sweet treat to cool off after a fun day. Their ice cream flavors change every day, with rotating flavors like sweet cream, strawberry, chocolate, brown butter, cinnamon toast crunch, dole whips, sorbets, and more. Plus, you can also choose from various cone dips such as peanut butter, chocolate, cherry, and toasted coconut!

Take a look at our Pigeon Forge cabins for rent to stay near all these places to get the best ice cream in Pigeon Forge TN. We look forward to seeing you in the Smokies very soon!